Contents
hide
If you are considering laser vision correction, you may be wondering whether PRK or LASIK is safer, more effective, and better suited to your individual needs.
Both PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy) and LASIK (Laser-Assisted In Situ Keratomileusis) are FDA-approved laser eye surgeries designed to correct vision permanently:
- Nearsightedness (myopia)
- Farsightedness (hyperopia)
- Astigmatism
Both procedures use an excimer laser to reshape the cornea. This allows light to focus more clearly on the retina and can improve your vision.
Each surgery changes the cornea in a different way. The recovery process is also different for each one.
It is important to understand these differences before deciding which procedure is right for you.
PRK vs LASIK: The Main Difference
The main difference between PRK and LASIK is how the surgeon accesses the cornea during the procedure.
🔹LASIK
In LASIK, the surgeon makes a thin flap in the cornea and lifts it. The laser changes the tissue under the flap. After the laser is used, the flap is put back in place.
🔹PRK
In PRK, the surgeon removes the thin outer layer of the cornea, called the epithelium. The laser reshapes the cornea’s surface. The epithelium grows back on its own over the next few days.
This difference affects several important aspects of the procedures, including:
- Recovery time
- Comfort level
- Risk profile
- Long-term structural stability
How PRK and LASIK Work (Step-by-Step)
What Happens During LASIK?
LASIK is the most commonly performed laser eye surgery worldwide.
During LASIK:
- Numbing drops are applied.
- A femtosecond laser creates a thin corneal flap.
- The flap is lifted.
- An excimer laser reshapes the cornea.
- The flap is repositioned — no stitches required.
The laser portion usually takes less than 30 seconds per eye.
Most patients notice clearer vision within 24–48 hours.
What Happens During PRK?
PRK was developed before LASIK and has over 30 years of clinical data.
During PRK:
- Numbing drops are applied.
- The outer epithelial layer is gently removed.
- The excimer laser reshapes the corneal surface.
- A protective bandage contact lens is placed.
- The epithelium regenerates over 3–5 days.
Because PRK does not create a flap, more of the cornea’s natural strength is preserved.
PRK vs LASIK Recovery: What to Expect
Recovery time is often a key factor for many people when deciding between PRK and LASIK.
LASIK Recovery
- Vision often improves within 24–48 hours.
- Minimal discomfort
- Return to work in 1–2 days.
- Mild dryness for weeks to months
Most people find that recovery after LASIK is quick and usually causes little discomfort.
PRK Recovery
- Blurry vision for several days
- Light sensitivity
- Burning or gritty sensation for 2–4 days
- Bandage contact lens for about a week
- Functional vision returns in 1–2 weeks.
- Final clarity may take 1–3 months.
PRK requires more patience during recovery. However, the long-term results are similar to those with LASIK.
PRK vs LASIK Results: Is One More Effective?
Long-term studies show:
- Both procedures have similar success rates.
- Over 90% of patients achieve 20/20 vision or better.
- Over 95% achieve driving-level vision (20/40 or better).
When performed on properly selected candidates by experienced surgeons, visual outcomes are essentially equivalent.
The main differences between PRK and LASIK are not in the final clarity of vision. Instead, they are in how quickly vision improves and how each procedure changes the cornea.
Is PRK Safer Than LASIK?
The answer depends on the unique structure of your eyes.
LASIK carries flap-related risks, including:
- Flap displacement (rare)
- Flap wrinkles
- Higher early dry eye risk
PRK does not require a corneal flap. This means it avoids the risk of flap-related complications.
Because PRK does not create a corneal flap, it may be safer for:
- People with thin corneas
- Athletes or military personnel
- Individuals at risk of eye trauma
- Borderline corneal thickness
For many patients, LASIK is perfectly safe.
For some people with certain eye structures, PRK may be a safer option to help preserve corneal strength.
For some people with certain eye structures, PRK may be a safer option to help preserve corneal strength.
PRK vs LASIK Risks and Complications
Both PRK and LASIK are considered safe procedures. However, it is important to remember that no surgery is completely without risk.
Possible risks include:
- Dry eye
- Night glare or halos
- Under-correction or over-correction
- Regression
- Corneal ectasia (rare)
- Infection (very rare)
LASIK has unique flap-related risks.
PRK has a higher risk of short-term corneal haze. With modern treatment, this haze is usually temporary.
PRK has a higher risk of short-term corneal haze. With modern treatment, this haze is usually temporary.
Serious vision-related complications are rare when either procedure is performed by an experienced surgeon who follows proper safety protocols.
Who Is a Good Candidate for LASIK?
You may qualify for LASIK if:
- You are over 18
- Your prescription is stable.
- Your corneas are thick enough.
- You do not have severe dry eye.
- You do not have keratoconus.
- You are not pregnant or breastfeeding.
Who Is a Better Candidate for PRK?
PRK may be preferred if:
- You have thin corneas.
- You have large pupils.
- You participate in contact sports.
- You are in military or high-impact professions.
- You want to avoid flap-related risks.
Some surgeons may recommend PRK instead of LASIK for people who are borderline candidates. PRK can help preserve more of the cornea’s strength.
PRK vs LASIK Cost
In the United States:
- Average cost ranges from $2,000 to $3,500 per eye.
- LASIK and PRK pricing are usually similar.
Cost varies based on:
- Surgeon experience
- Technology used
- Location
- Post-operative care included
Both PRK and LASIK are considered elective procedures. This means they are usually not covered by insurance.
Financing plans are often available.
Pros and Cons of PRK vs LASIK
When you compare PRK and LASIK, the main differences are recovery time, comfort, and the extent of corneal reshaping. Both work well, but each has its own pros and cons.
✔ LASIK Pros
- Faster recovery – Most people see much better within a day or two.
- Minimal early discomfort – You might feel a little irritation for a few hours, but it usually doesn’t last long.
- Rapid return to daily activities – You can usually go back to work and your normal routine in a day or two.
✔ LASIK Cons
- Permanent corneal flap – The thin flap in your cornea stays there for life, which means there’s a small chance of flap problems later on.
- Higher chance of temporary dry eye – Your eyes might feel dry for the first few months after surgery.
- Not ideal for thin corneas – If your corneas are thin, LASIK might not be the best choice for you.
✔ PRK Pros
- No corneal flap – The surface of your eye heals on its own, which is good if you’re at risk for eye injuries.
- Preserves more corneal structure – Doctors often recommend PRK if your corneas are thin.
- Lower long-term flap risk – Since there’s no flap, you don’t have to worry about flap problems down the road.
✔ PRK Cons
- Slower visual recovery – It can take a few days to see well, and your vision may take a few weeks to reach its clearest.
- More short-term discomfort – Your eyes might burn or feel sensitive to light for a few days while they heal.
- Longer stabilization period – Your vision might go up and down a bit during the first few weeks as your eyes heal.
Both PRK and LASIK can give you great results if your eye doctor ensures you’re a good candidate. The best choice depends on how thick your corneas are, your lifestyle, and how you feel about the recovery.
PRK vs LASIK: Which Procedure Is Better?
There is not a single best procedure for everyone. The right choice depends on your corneal thickness, prescription, eye surface health, and your daily activities.
For many people, LASIK is preferred because:
- Your vision often improves quickly, sometimes in just a day or two.
- Any discomfort after surgery is usually mild and goes away quickly.
- LASIK works well if your corneas are healthy and thick enough.
But PRK might be safer or a better fit if:
- Your corneas are thin or borderline for creating a LASIK flap.
- You have a higher risk of eye injury. This can include playing contact sports, serving in the military, or having a physically demanding job.
- You aren’t a good candidate for LASIK, but you still want laser vision correction.
Both surgeries can give you great results if you’re the right candidate. The most important thing is to get a full eye exam with a doctor who does both PRK and LASIK, and who picks the best option for your eyes; not just what’s popular.
What Really Determines the Best Option?
The decision is based on a detailed pre-operative evaluation, including:
- Corneal thickness (pachymetry)
- Prescription strength and stability
- Corneal shape and topography
- Ocular surface health (dry eye status)
- Lifestyle and occupational risk factors
- Surgeon’s clinical assessment
With an experienced doctor, both PRK and LASIK can give you good long-term results. The safest and best choice is the one that fits your eyes.
How to Choose the Right LASIK or PRK Surgeon
When you think about PRK and LASIK, the doctor you choose is often more important than the surgery itself. Both surgeries can work well, but results depend on good screening, the doctor’s skill, and good care after surgery.
Here’s what to look for:
- Board certification in ophthalmology and formal refractive surgery training
- Extensive experience performing both LASIK and PRK (not just one procedure)
- Use of modern diagnostic technology (corneal topography, tomography, pachymetry, dry eye evaluation)
- Willingness to share complication rates and outcomes data
- A doctor who explains what to expect and does not promise perfect vision.
Do not choose a surgery or a surgeon based only on cost.
When considering laser vision correction, safety should always be your top priority.
PRK vs LASIK: FAQs
Is PRK more painful than LASIK?
Yes. PRK usually causes more discomfort for a few days because the surface of the cornea needs to heal. LASIK usually causes less discomfort for a shorter time.
Yes. PRK usually causes more discomfort for a few days because the surface of the cornea needs to heal. LASIK usually causes less discomfort for a shorter time.
How long does PRK vision fluctuate?
Vision after PRK can change for several weeks. Most people can see well enough within 1 to 2 weeks, but it may take 1 to 3 months for vision to stabilize fully.
Vision after PRK can change for several weeks. Most people can see well enough within 1 to 2 weeks, but it may take 1 to 3 months for vision to stabilize fully.
Can PRK or LASIK cause blindness?
Permanent blindness is very rare when a qualified surgeon does the surgery. Both surgeries are safe for people who are good candidates.
Permanent blindness is very rare when a qualified surgeon does the surgery. Both surgeries are safe for people who are good candidates.
Final Verdict: PRK vs LASIK
Both PRK and LASIK are considered safe and effective options for long-term vision correction.
The main differences between the two procedures are found in:
- Recovery speed
- Corneal structure
- Risk tolerance
LASIK offers faster visual recovery.
PRK may help provide greater structural stability for people with certain eye characteristics.
PRK may help provide greater structural stability for people with certain eye characteristics.
The safest approach is a comprehensive refractive evaluation, including:
- Corneal topography
- Pachymetry
- Tear film assessment
- Pupil measurement
When doctors choose the right surgery for each person, both PRK and LASIK can give very good results.
If you are considering laser eye surgery, it is important to schedule a full consultation with an experienced ophthalmologist. This will help determine which option is safest for your eyes.
